Horror Dialogue That Doesn't Sound Cheesy

Image by: Mario Azzi

Creating dialogue for your horror screenplay can be tricky. Push too far, and it sounds campy or cartoonish. Pull too little, and your characters feel flat or emotionless in the face of terror. Because horror thrives on heightened stakes, the temptation is to lean into melodrama or over-explaining, but that's precisely when dialogue collapses into cheese.

The truth about creating great dialogue in horror is that it works best when it's grounded, specific, and layered with subtext. A terrified character doesn't need to announce they're terrified. Their words, silence, and choices should show it. Here's how to craft dialogue that heightens fear without breaking immersion.

---

Cut the Obvious Statements

Characters don't need to narrate what's happening in front of them. Lines like "What was that noise?" or "We need to get out of here!" often feel forced because the audience already knows. These lines waste valuable space and kill the tension you're trying to build.

Instead, you want to focus on what characters don't want to say out loud. If someone hears a noise upstairs, maybe they try to ignore it or downplay it with humor. Or their silence speaks volumes. When dialogue resists the obvious, it feels more authentic and unsettling.

Use Subtext Over Screaming

Fear makes people hide, deflect, or deny. If every character just shouts about being scared, it gets monotonous. Instead, think about how different personalities process fear: the skeptic makes jokes, the caretaker reassures, the control freak issues commands.

Let dialogue reflect coping strategies instead of blunt emotion. A line like, "It's probably just the pipes," tells us both what the character says and what they're refusing to admit. Subtext layers tension because the audience knows more than the character is willing to confess.

Anchor Dialogue in Character Voice

This was something I really struggled with when I first started writing horror stories. Generic dialogue sounds cheesy because it could come from anyone. Horror scripts especially suffer when every character delivers the same bland fear responses. If your dialogue feels interchangeable, your scares will too.

You want to make sure to give each character a distinct rhythm, vocabulary, and worldview. The stoner doesn't react the same way as the single mom, and the grieving scientist doesn't crack the same jokes as the frat guy. Even in terror, their voices should remain unique and consistent.

Keep Exposition Minimal and Natural

Exposition-heavy dialogue, explaining the monster, the curse, or the rules, often derails horror pacing. If your characters spend entire scenes explaining the plot, it feels forced and instantly drains fear.

A better way to approach it is to deliver the information in fragments, arguments, or slips of emotion. Characters should resist giving full clarity until it's absolutely necessary. Sometimes it's scarier when they're wrong, confused, or unwilling to share what they know. The less neatly your dialogue "solves" things, the more dread you're able to sustain.

Silence Is a Line Too

Writers tend to forget that silence is also dialogue. What's not being said can be more terrifying than a page of screaming. Pauses, cut-off sentences, or characters refusing to speak create unease because the audience fills in the blanks.

Use ellipses, dashes, or unfinished thoughts to create rhythm and hesitation. A line ending mid-thought can feel like a character is too afraid to continue, or that something interrupted them. Silence invites the reader to imagine what the character is avoiding, and imagination is where fear grows.

Watch Out for Unintentional Camp

Camp has its place in horror, but only when intentional. When dialogue unintentionally strays into melodrama, "We can't let the evil win!" or corny quips mid-crisis, it can kill the mood you're building.

Start reading your dialogue aloud. If it sounds like a line from a parody, cut or rewrite it. Keep your lines conversational, grounded in the situation, and emotionally truthful, even in the wildest supernatural setup.

---

Final Thoughts

Great horror dialogue doesn't announce the horror; it dodges, denies, jokes, or stays silent. When your lines are rooted in character voice and subtext, they heighten the terror rather than deflate it. The best dialogue doesn't just deliver words, it reveals personality, resists truth, and lingers in the audience's mind long after the page turns.

So cut the obvious. Lean into the unsaid. And let your characters sound human, even as the world turns inhuman around them.

📄 Want help refining your horror dialogue?

🔐 Download my Dialogue Polishing Checklist—a tool to test whether your dialogue is authentic, character-driven, and scare-enhancing.