My Comfort Horror Rewatches (Yes, That's a Thing)

Image by: Peter Forster

If you're here, you probably already get it: horror isn't just blood and screams. For some of us, it's strangely soothing. A familiar place to explore big, messy fears and come out the other side still safe on our couch with tea (or let's be real: a generous glass of red.)

So today, I wanted to share my personal list of comfort horror rewatches. The movies I return to again and again when I want that cozy little shiver. Some are bleak, some are bonkers, all of them remind me why I fell in love with horror in the first place.

---

A Quiet Place (2018)

It's the tension for me. The way this film plays with silence, forcing you to hang on every creak, every breath - it's oddly calming, like holding your breath underwater. But beneath the creature feature is a story about parents willing to do anything to protect their kids. It hits that same deep chord every time.

Event Horizon (1997)

Yes, this one is dark. But there's something cathartic about a horror movie that commits so fully to cosmic dread. The gothic visuals in deep space, the hellish hallucinations, it's sci-fi horror at its nastiest. I rewatch it when I want to remember how fearless genre filmmaking can be.

The Black Phone (2021)

I love a horror movie that doubles as a survival story. Watching Finney claw his way our, mentally and physically, is pure resilience porn. Plus, there's a twisted comfort in knowing exactly when the jump scares are coming so I can half-laugh at myself bracing for them. And Ethan Hawke's performance was fantastic! I'm looking forward to heading to the theater to watch the sequel when it releases on October 17, 2025.

It (2017)

Some people rewatch feel-good nostalgia movies, I rewatch It. The Losers Club gives me all the coming-of-age friendship warmth I could ask for... wrapped in Pennywise's nightmare grin. Every time, I notice a new moment of bravery. It makes the inevitable horrors somehow hopeful.

The Babadook (2104)

This one feels like putting on an old sweater. It's about grief and rage and motherhood, all hiding under the bed. It's messy and human and ugly, which makes it honest. Sometimes I rewatch it just to sit with my own shadows a while.

Tucker and Dale Vs. Evil (2010)

When I truly need a pick-me-up, I go straight here. Horror gets turned on its head in the funniest, sweetest way. It's proof that horror can be about kindness and misunderstandings as much as axes and impalements. (Okay, maybe both).

Stir of Echoes (1999)

This one slides under the skin in a subtle, eerie way. And let's be honest, we all need a little more Kevin Bacon in our lives, even if his unraveling feels personal. It's like watching someone pick at the scabs of grief and guilt until the ghosts finally spill out. It's haunting, sure, but there's also a strangely satisfying sense of closure that makes it feel safe to revisit.

---

Final Thought

I think for some of us, horror is a way to face down the monsters, internal or otherwise, on our own terms. To watch the worst happen, and then breathe out, alive and intact. Somehow, it makes the everyday fears a little easier to carry. Do you have a favorite horror movie to rewatch, or several? Share your list in the comments below.

And if you’re as obsessed with horror as I am, join my members-only community for script breakdowns, interviews, live horror writing sessions, and more. [Click here to explore the tiers and see what’s inside!]